🔗 Share this article

Director Baby Ruth Villarama and her team board a diverse assortment of boats and ships to chronicle the continuing conflict and its effects between the Philippine nation and the People's Republic of China over control of the recently named West Philippine Sea. These waters, viewed by most nations apart from China as part of the Philippines' EEZ, has seen escalating incursions by Chinese vessels. While some are fishing boats, most notably maritime militia that have been accused of harassing, collided with, and tried to seize Filipino boats in the context of the ongoing standoff.

Some footage are incredibly gripping, though often the conflict unfolds as a war of words of maritime bluster. Crews aboard opposing vessels exchange heated declarations, peppered with technical legalese, engaging in a kind of radio diplomacy.

Sustaining the Outposts

The film's title highlights the critical efforts by the Filipino military to resupply foodstuffs to remote islands in the West Philippine Sea where personnel are stationed for long, solitary stretches. These "islands" are often mere dollops of sand in shallow waters, no larger than a football pitch, accessible only by fast-moving motorized rafts.

These trips prove evidently terrifying for the cargo of baby goats, which are crammed in with canned goods and further materials. Viewers see the creatures seeking for better balance as the craft race across the rolling sea.

Voices from the Shoal

The film also follows communities around the more populated Scarborough Shoal, who express concern over reduced harvests attributed to the persistent presence of foreign fishing vessels in their customary waters.

A Compelling Subject, Imperfect Execution

From a technical standpoint, the documentary is somewhat hampered by a slightly disjointed storytelling structure and a soundtrack that can feel a bit heavy-handed, overemphasizing the emotional beats. Yet, it remains a important look of a critical subject that gets scant attention outside its region.